Eliciting and reconstructing programme theory: an exercise in translating theory into practice

Tools

Siebert, P. ORCID: 0000-0003-3817-229X and Myles, P., 2019. Eliciting and reconstructing programme theory: an exercise in translating theory into practice. Evaluation, 25 (4), pp. 469-476. ISSN 1356-3890

Preview

Text
14712_a71_Siebert.pdf - Post-print
Download (155kB) | Preview

Official URL: http://doi.org/10.1177/1356389019870211

Abstract

The importance of evaluation to demonstrate the effectiveness of policies, programmes and interventions is widely recognised. Evaluation in the context of public health and healthcare is viewed as a complicated exercise, particularly when dealing with complex interventions involving multiple partners, multiple components and multiple outcomes. Eliciting the programme theory is an important starting point of an evaluation process to enable the link between theory and action to be articulated. This article gives a pragmatic account of the practicalities of working with stakeholders as they embark on a formative evaluation of a complex public health initiative, using a using a theory-based approach. Drawing on the principles of Leeuw’s strategic assessment, we planned a workshop to reflect the four stages of this approach–group formation, assumption surfacing, dialectical debate and synthesis. Stakeholders took part in four activities–Free Listing, Sphere of Influence, Beattie’s Theoretical Framework and Programme Concept Mapping. We found that our elicitation approach was particularly suited to reconstructing the programme theory in a non-threatening and playful environment, bringing about an alignment of programme theories by consensus and reducing anxiety.

Item Type:

Journal article

Publication Title:

Evaluation

Creators:

Siebert, P. and Myles, P.

Publisher:

Sage

Date:

1 October 2019

Volume:

Number: