Is gender equality in brain damage ‘progress’ for women and sport?

Tools

Hardwicke, J. ORCID: 0000-0002-1152-0920, AlHashmi, R., Forbes, D., Paetcher, C. ORCID: 0000-0003-3050-5571, Pocock, M. ORCID: 0000-0001-9660-1879, Taylor, K. ORCID: 0000-0002-9611-3020, Yeagers, D. ORCID: 0009-0001-3017-0524 and Matthews, C. ORCID: 0000-0001-8561-2863, 2024. Is gender equality in brain damage ‘progress’ for women and sport? International Review for the Sociology of Sport. ISSN 1012-6902 (Forthcoming)

Preview

Text
1867998_Hardwicke.pdf - Post-print
Download (259kB) | Preview

Abstract

This commentary sits within a context of growing cultural concern over brain damage that occurs in many of the Western world’s most popular, profitable and prized sports. After laying out evidence demonstrating this point, we discuss the increasing inclusion of women within sports which involve regular and routinised brain injuries. We problematise this apparent ‘progress’ with the title of our commentary. In particular, rather than offering some simplified yes/no answer, we argue that in light of the five decades of social scientific scholarship documenting the various harms produced by performance impact sports, working toward gender equality in brain damage is a nonsensical outcome. So, while there is clear evidence from academic gender studies that progress has been made toward tackling issues of exclusion and various forms of discrimination against women and girls in performance sport spaces, there has not been concomitant progress made in tackling the ways bodies and brains are often broken down, damaged and sometimes destroyed during participation in such sports. We do not suggest that consenting adults should be prohibited from enjoying impact sports and our aim with this commentary is not driven by a paternalistic, patriarchal belief which reflects historical notions around sportswomen being the ‘fairer’ sex, nor that responses to sport-acquired brain injury should be sex- or gender-specific. Rather, we conclude by suggesting that the emerging science on sport-acquired brain injuries should serve as an important inflection point to those leaders, organisers, practitioners and scholars working in this area to reconsider how we imagine, promote and structure sport - for everyone.

Item Type:

Journal article

Publication Title:

International Review for the Sociology of Sport

Creators:

Hardwicke, J., AlHashmi, R., Forbes, D., Paetcher, C., Pocock, M., Taylor, K., Yeagers, D. and Matthews, C.

Publisher:

SAGE Publications

Date:

20 February 2024

ISSN:

1012-6902